Property Managed Funds vs. DIY Investing: Which Path is Right for You?

Let’s be honest: the Australian property market has long been a cornerstone of wealth creation. But when you decide to turn that “great Australian dream” into a tangible investment strategy, a critical question emerges. Do you pull on the gloves, grab the tools, and become a DIY landlord? Or do you partner with experts and leverage the power of property managed funds?

It’s the classic “hands-on” versus “hands-off” dilemma. And there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right path depends entirely on your time, expertise, risk appetite, and overall financial goals.

In this guide, we’ll break down both approaches, stripping away the jargon to help you see clearly which route might be the best fit for your investment journey.

Understanding the Two Paths: A Quick Overview

DIY Property Investing: This is the traditional route. You are the CEO, project manager, and problem-solver. You personally research the market, secure a loan, purchase a property, find tenants, and manage every aspect of maintenance and compliance. You have direct, physical ownership of a specific asset.

Property Managed Funds: This is a more modern, institutional approach. Here, you pool your capital with other investors into a fund that is professionally managed by a team of experts. The fund manager handles everything: acquisition, management, and eventual sale of a portfolio of properties. You own units in the fund, not a specific brick-and-mortar asset.

Now, let’s dive into the nitty-gritty.

The DIY Investor: The Hands-On Landlord

The Allure of Control

The biggest draw for the DIY path is total control. You get to call all the shots. You choose the exact suburb, the specific street, and the perfect property. You decide on the renovation plans, the rent price, and who your tenant will be. For many, this tangible sense of ownership is incredibly rewarding.

The Reality of the Time Commitment

However, this control comes at a cost: your time. Being a landlord is rarely a passive endeavour. It involves:

• Endless Research: Analysing market data, suburb reports, and rental yields.
• The Buying Process: Navigating auctions, negotiating with agents, and wading through legal conveyancing.
• Tenant Management: Advertising the property, conducting background checks, handling lease agreements, and managing rent collection.
• The “3 AM Phone Call”: Dealing with emergency repairs, like a burst pipe or a broken heater.

As the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) outlines, there’s also a significant administrative burden in tracking expenses, depreciation, and ensuring your tax returns are accurate.

The Financial Hurdles and Concentration Risk

DIY investing requires substantial capital for a deposit, stamp duty, and legal fees. Your investment is also highly concentrated. Your entire success hinges on the performance of a single asset (or a small handful). A problematic tenant, a major structural issue, or a local market downturn can have a dramatic impact on your wealth.

Property Managed Funds: The Hands-Off Approach

The Power of Professional Management

When you invest in property managed funds, you’re essentially hiring a full-time team of experts to do the heavy lifting. This includes market analysts, acquisition specialists, property managers, and legal professionals. Their full-time job is to identify and manage high-quality assets to maximise returns for you, the investor.

This professional management is a significant advantage, transforming property from a part-time job into a truly passive investment.

Instant Diversification: Your Safety Net

This is arguably one of the most compelling benefits. Instead of tying your fortune to one house, your investment is spread across a portfolio of properties. This could include a mix of residential, commercial, or industrial assets across different geographic locations. If one property has a vacant period or one market softens, the others in the portfolio can help balance it out, significantly reducing your risk.

Accessibility and Scalability

Many property managed funds have a lower entry point than buying a whole property, making the asset class accessible to a wider range of investors. Furthermore, it’s incredibly scalable. As you have more capital to invest, you can simply purchase more units in the fund without the hassle of securing another mortgage or going through another entire purchase process.

Side-by-Side Comparison: Your Decision Matrix

Factor	DIY Property Investing	Property Managed Funds
Control	High. You make all decisions.	Lower. The fund manager makes strategic decisions.
Time Commitment	High. Active, hands-on management.	Low. Truly passive investment.
Diversification	Low and difficult to achieve.	High. Instant portfolio diversification.
Expertise Required	High. You need to be the expert.	Low. You leverage the fund’s expertise.
Liquidity	Low. Selling a property can take months.	Higher. Fund structures often allow for redemptions.
Costs	Transactional (stamp duty, legals) and ongoing maintenance.	Management fees, but no direct transaction costs.

So, Which Path is Right for YOU?

Ask yourself these key questions:

1. Do I have the time and expertise? Are you excited by the prospect of researching suburbs and managing tenants, or does that sound like a nightmare?
2. What is my risk tolerance? Are you comfortable with your investment being concentrated in one asset, or does a diversified portfolio give you more peace of mind?
3. What are my financial goals? Are you looking for a project you can actively grow, or are you seeking a passive, set-and-forget addition to your portfolio?

If your answers lean towards wanting more time, less stress, and a diversified, professionally managed portfolio, then exploring property managed funds is a logical next step.

At Real Estate Science Fund, we believe in a scientific approach to property investment. Our property managed funds are designed for investors who want access to the wealth-building potential of Australian real estate without the hassle and high risk of going it alone. We handle the complex analysis, acquisition, and management, allowing you to focus on your life while your investment works for you. <a href=”https://realestatesciencefund.com.au/”>Learn more about our investment philosophy and fund offerings here</a>.

The Final Verdict

There is no “bad” choice—only the choice that is right for your personal circumstances. The DIY route offers control and a tangible asset for those with the time and skill. Property managed funds offer diversification, professional management, and a passive experience for those looking to optimise their time and mitigate risk.

In today’s complex market, understanding your options is the first step to making an empowered investment decision.

---

Disclaimer: This blog post contains general information only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should consider seeking independent legal, financial, taxation or other advice to check how the information relates to your unique circumstances.